The concept of arthroscopic knee surgery to “clean up” loose tissue in order to reduce knee pain had come into question as early as 2002, when a New England Journal of Medicine article found that people who had arthroscopic surgery did not have less pain or more movement than people who underwent a “fake” knee procedure. As you can imagine, this was very controversial and never accepted by the surgical community.
A recent article published in the New England Journal shows again that “Arthroscopic surgery for osteoarthritis of the knee provides no additional benefit to optimized physical and medical therapy. (ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT00158431 [ClinicalTrials.gov] .) ”
An MSNBC article and Video nicely capture the essence of their conclusions.
As another blow to the arthroscopic knee surgery, another New England Journal study was just published showing that up to 60% of people who had meniscus tears on their MRI actually had NO KNEE PAIN. Of those with arthritis and knee pain, 63% had meniscal tears. It stands to reason, then, that many people who have knee pain, and get an MRI showing a meniscus tear, will have, and have had, unnecessary and ineffective arthroscopic knee surgery to repair that painless tear. These people may have had a multitude of non-surgical causes for their pain.
That is why, at Regenerative Sciences, we approach knee pain from the perspective of Joint Preservation. This means that MRI images are only a part of whole picture. Muscles near the painful joint, as well as in other parts of the body, are treated to reduce stress on the joint and minimize pain prior to performing the Regenexx procedure
Tags: knee pain, knee surgery alternative, New England Journal of Medicine, Regenerative Sciences, Regenexx, stem cell therapy
[...] capability in this area of the knee, sutures are unlikely to hold this in place for very long. In addition, most of these patients with large parts of their meniscus removed, have other problems…There’s also significant scientific doubt that many of these meniscus tears are causing pain [...]
[...] he presented to our clinic and we determined on exam that this was likely the cause of his pain. As you know, research now shows that knee meniscus tears are not always the cause of pain, so a good exam is now needed to make sure. He decided to avoid surgery and have his own stem [...]