Chat with us, powered by LiveChat

How Does Prolotherapy Solution Impact PRP and Stem Cells?

POSTED ON IN Latest News BY Chris Centeno

We’ve seen a number of providers around the country injecting prolotherapy solution with PRP or stem cells. Is this a good idea? As I’ll show, regrettably, this is a just another example of the stem cell wild west where providers mix and match therapies with little basic science understanding or testing of what’s going on. All of this happens at the patient’s expense.

Understanding Prolotherapy and Osmolarity

Before we explore more in-depth on how prolotherapy solution impacts live stem cells and platelets, let me make sure everyone understands prolotherapy and how it works. Prolotherapy is a basic regenerative-medicine treatment that involves injecting certain extra-concentrated solutions for the purpose of causing a brief inflammatory healing response. When used as a treatment all on its own, it can be effective at, for example, tightening lax ligaments and eliminating pain in the tendons.

To fully grasp prolotherapy and how it impacts stem cells and platelets, it’s first important to understand or refresh your knowledge on some basic physical chemistry. Watching my video above will provide you with some visuals to enhance the information below. First, you need to understand the concept of osmolarity.

Osmolarity is simply the concentration of a solution. Water always flows out of less-concentrated solutions into more-concentrated solutions. The osmolarity of the body, for example, is at 0.9% concentration, the same as saline or salt water. Compare this to the osmolarity of a common prolotherapy solution, which is typically at 10–15%. Because of this high concentration, we would call prolotherapy hyperosmolar (high osmolarity).

Before I dive into prolotherapy and platelets, let me give you an example of how powerful small changes in the concentration (osmolarity) of a solution can be. If I take your red blood cells (RBCs) and put them into distilled water, I will have changed the osmolarity of the solution they normally live in (serum) from 0.9% to 0%. Basically, a tiny change of less than 1%. Despite this small change, your red blood cells will explode in about 10 seconds. Why? Remember, fluid flows from less concentrated to more, so here water flows from the 0% distilled water solution into the RBCs which have a concentration inside of 0.9%.

So what happens to platelets and stem cells in prolotherapy solution? Let’s begin with platelets.

How Prolotherapy Impacts Platelets

Let’s first explore what happens to platelets in saline, which, as mentioned, is the same osmolarity as the body. In saline, the concentration of the solution is about the same as the concentration in the platelets. What this means is that the water doesn’t really flow one direction or the other.

In a prolotherapy solution, the hyperosmolar concentration is a lot higher than the concentration of the fluid inside the platelets. This means the water flows out of the platelets (less concentrated) into the solution (more concentrated), basically dehydrating the platelets and turning them into platelet “raisins.” And while we have no research on how dried-out platelets might perform, injecting prolotherapy with platelet-rich plasma (PRP) is likely delivering broken platelets.

Why would platelet raisins be a problem? Platelets deliver a precisely timed release of growth factors based on what’s going on in their environment. These growth factors then stimulate specific parts of the healing process. Hence, deforming platelets and likely damaging them by dehydrating them likely impacts this precisely timed release of critical factors that assist healing.

How Prolotherapy Impacts Stem Cells

Now let’s take a look at what happens to stem cells injected with prolotherapy solution. We did research on this many years ago. Based on that research, a common 10–15% prolotherapy solution completely killed the stem cells. Even at 5%, a solution that’s commonly used not for prolotherapy but to treat overactive or irritated nerves (i.e., a sweet caudal epidural), caused about half the stem cells to die. So why the toxic effect on the cells? For the same reason discussed above. The prolotherapy solution is hyperosmolar and sucks the water out of the stem cells, causing them to die. Think about it based on your own experience. If someone sucked half the water out of your body in seconds, you wouldn’t last long.

So why use prolotherapy solution for any purpose, and why does it help ligaments and tendons heal? When used alone, it’s a chemical debridement agent. Meaning it purposefully injures, or even kills, the superficial layer of cells in the tissues. This small amount of local cell death causes a brief inflammatory repair cycle. Basically, it gives you another bite at the healing apple if your tissues failed to heal after your initial injury. This is similar to a surgeon purposefully injuring a tendon by making small incisions or a doctor pulling the dead tissue out of a nonhealing skin wound, causing small amounts of tissue damage to prompt healing (debridement).

How Prolotherapy Solution and Cells Can Be Used Safely

Since the osmolar effects of prolotherapy solution take place in seconds, it can be used at a different time than cells. Hence, it can be injected BEFORE the cells are injected. We usually do this days before, so that all effects have run their course before the cells hit the area. It shouldn’t be used right after cells are injected into an area, as that will kill the new cells. However, after the cells have set up shop and helped the repair process, it could be used again (commonly many weeks after the stem cells are injected).

Other Common Injection Protocols that Kill Cells

If you think this little brain slip is a rarity in the wild west of stem cells, think again. In fact, it’s common. For example, orthopedic surgeons and pain-management doctors love an anesthetic called bupivacaine and high-dose steroid anti-inflammatory drugs (e.g., cortisone). Many inject these with PRP or stem cells, not knowing that these substances kill local cartilage and any stem cells being injected. We see many alternative-health practitioners, plastic surgeons, and age-management clinics injecting stem cells IV to treat brain disorders, not knowing that because of the pulmonary first-pass effect, these cells will end up in the lungs and not in the brain. These are just a few examples of the nonsense protocols being used.

Why is this happening? There is no education in residency or fellowship in the cell biology of PRP or stem cell therapy. That means your famous orthopedic surgeon who takes care of [insert sports team name here] doesn’t have a clue about what kills cells, and what he does know about orthobiologics could fill only a small pamphlet, and most of that would likely be inaccurate. The same holds true for countless doctors who took a weekend course on the subject. It’s even worse for alternative-health practitioners, who have much poorer science backgrounds than physicians.

The upshot? When you hear of an injection protocol like “we inject prolotherapy solution with cells,” question everything. Ninety-nine percent of the medical doctors, chiropractors, naturopaths, and acupuncturists offering “stem cell therapy”don’t know what they don’t know. Meaning, many put together homegrown injection protocols that kill the very cells they say will heal your injury. We’ve never done it that way at Regenexx, which is why we have a multimillion-dollar lab facility at our Colorado HQ site. We test these things before we offer them to patients, to make sure that the cells you get are alive and in the best possible health!

    *DISCLAIMER: Like all medical procedures, Regenexx® Procedures have a success and failure rate. Patient reviews and testimonials on this site should not be interpreted as a statement on the effectiveness of our treatments for anyone else.
    Providers listed on the Regenexx website are for informational purposes only and are not a recommendation from Regenexx for a specific provider or a guarantee of the outcome of any treatment you receive.

    comments

    David Drez says

    Is it ok to do intrarticular knee injection of stem cells and amnion in separate syringes?
    What should be time interval between knee injections of stem cells and/or amnion ?

    replies

    Regenexx Team says

    David,
    Based on the research that we did in the lab, stem cells had more stress and performed poorly in the presence of Amnion. Hence I wouldn't combine those two together.

    replies

    Dana says

    I’ve already had a menisectomy and microfracture in both knees but there’s some chondromalacia left behind, particularly in my left knee. Since I didn’t have stem cell injections immediately after surgery, has the healing window passed? Or could you use prolotherapy to simulate a post op condition and inject stem cells a couple of days after prolotherapy? Finally, do stem cells treat chondromalacia?

    replies

    Regenexx Team says

    Dana,
    Yes, we treat stem cells to treat Chondromalacia. Polotherapy is the first of 3 treatments which make up a Regenexx SD stem cell procedure. Please see: https://www.regenexx.com/second-chance-with-regenexx-knee-stem-cell-injections/ Both surgeries are a net negative, so we'd be treating the Chondromalacia as well as treating the issues caused by them. We'd need a recent MRI for a Candidacy eval, and a thorough exam. To proceed with that, please submit the Candidate form to the right of the blog, or call 855 622 7838.

    replies

    Fain Zimmerman says

    If an IV injection of stem cells goes to the lungs, can this be used as a treatment for lung conditions, such as COPD?

    replies

    Regenexx Team says

    Fain,
    Please see: https://www.regenexx.com/iv-stem-cells-clotting/

    replies

    Dr. W Francois Louw says

    Dear Dr. Centeno
    While I agree with many of your positions, I have to question the accuracy of your statements on osmolarity of D5W and higher concentrations of dextrose.
    The osmolarity of D5W is around 260 mosm/kg, and N serum is 275–295 mosm/kg. Hence we should not expect to see an osmotic shift out of cells (platelets) with D5W as it is hypotonic
    Even D15W's osmol is only about 757 mosm/kg, so only about 2,5 times higher than serum.
    To equate a dextrose "percentage", say 15 % (i.e. 150mg/ml) to a 15 times higher osmolarity is not correct, but I agree that an osmotic shift out of platelets / stem cells will take place at these hyperosmolar concentrations.
    Thanks for the good work you're doing in this field BTW.

    replies

    Chris Centeno says

    The stem cell kill could be due to a different cause other than osmolar. However, hard to argue with the experimental evidence that we generated (50% kill rate of MSCs with 5% dextrose) until someone else replicates that experiment. D5W is typically given to pull water out of the circulation and into cells, so instead of platelet raisins, I would expect that you would get swollen or exploded platelets. Hence the reason we keep all 5% and up dextrose solutions away from stem cell and PRP therapies. On platelets, I haven't seen any experimental evidence on 5% dextrose, hence we as doctors would have an ethical duty to avoid mixing these two until we can have at least some in-vitro evidence. We don't use much 5% dextrose solution, so it will be up to someone else to do those experiements. Maybe someone has already published on this topic of D5W and platelets?

    replies

    Elizabeth W says

    What would you recommend for an annural tear causing radicilulitis?

    replies

    Regenexx Team says

    Hi Elizabeth,
    We'd need more information through the Candidacy process to advise on a particular case, but generally, Please see: https://www.regenexx.com/blog/stem-cell-disc-treatment/ To do that, please use the "Get Started" button here: https://www.regenexx.com/conditions-treated/spine/

    replies

    Ken says

    That was a good post.

    I have CCI. After I get stem cells I now know not to use neural prolotherapy (Dr. Lyftogt technique) that I do at present which helps to realign my neck with out self adjusting. My practitioner also uses Dr Gunn’s IMS (intramuscular stimulation) to realign my neck and back, when required..
    Now I understand that neural prolotherapy would be contraindicated for some time after stem cell injections I’m hoping that IMS is not contraindicated, so that my ligaments can regenerate with my spine in a neutral position as possible. The IMS practitioner I go to is top notch. Your thoughts on IMS treatment after stem cells to the neck. If yes, when?

    replies

    Regenexx Team says

    Hi Ken,
    When you say "get stem cells", do you mean you'll be getting the the PICL procedure (CCJ Instability procedure) at Regenexx HQ's, the Centeno Schultz Clinic in Colorado?

    replies

    Ken says

    Yes, I would like my neck assessed and treated at the Broomfield clinic.
    It’s my understanding that I may have to try the posterior approach first and then see if the anterior approach is still needed.
    Please advise.

    replies

    Regenexx Team says

    Hi Ken,
    Yes, there is specific criteria for the PICL (CCJ Instability) procedure including prior less invasive treatment. Please see: https://www.regenexx.com/blog/candidacy-for-ccj-instability-procedure/ We will contact you.

    replies

    Ken says

    What are the doctors opinion on IMS (Dr. Gunn’s) technique before and after stem cell procedure of neck to help align neck by relaxing muscle spasms in the neck? I find this treatment highly effective for this. When might one start this after the procedure? Healing in alignment, would be beneficial, I would think.

    replies

    Regenexx Team says

    Hi Ken,
    We use IMS regularly. Whether they would be appropriate before or after a procedure would be on a case by case basis and depend on the specific patient, what we are treating with what treatment.

    replies

    Add comment

    Your comment will be revised by the site if needed.

    About the Author

    Chris Centeno

    Christopher J. Centeno, M.D. is an international expert and specialist in regenerative medicine and the clinical use of mesenchymal stem cells in orthopedics. He is board certified in physical medicine as well as rehabilitation and in pain management through The American Board of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation.…

    View Profile

    Search Blog

    Categories