Amniotic Stem Cells and the Great Cell Therapy Deception
POSTED ON 10/4/2016 IN Regenerative Medicine Education BY Christopher Centeno
Many concerned physician colleagues have recently contacted me after attending a promotional event for an amniotic stem cell clinic where a chiropractic group or an organization that uses physician extenders such as nurse practitioners or PA's to inject patients was selling amniotic stem cell treatments. They have good reason to be concerned. If amniotic stem cells were truly the magic they are advertised to be, we would be interested in these products ourselves; however, when we did the research, we discovered one little problem with this advertising. It's fiction! Let me explain.
The Great Deception of Amniotic Stem Cells
Why is it fiction? We began looking at amniotic stem cells a long time ago when sales reps approached us claiming to have bottles of amniotic stem cells to sell. We were initially pretty stoked as if that were true it could be a game changer for our patients. However, since in my opinion, medical sales reps have the credibility of bad used car salesmen, we did the basic science research to determine the validity of these claims before we were willing to inject this stuff into patients. We began the project in our lab, but then kicked it to the Interventional Orthopedics Foundation as the number of new amniotic products appearing on the market soon outpaced our ability to keep up. There were a number of things the IOF research scientist looked at during his amniotic stem cell study, including the following:
- Whether or not these products had any living cells
- Whether or not these products helped older stem cells
- Whether or not these products had any growth factors that might be useful for patients
Using sophisticated equipment (seen in the video above), the IOF found no living cells. Despite clinics advertising that these amniotic preps have live cells, the cells were dead! Also, these products didn't help old cells perform better, nor did they have more growth factors than a simple and inexpensive PRP shot.
While many claim that these products are safe given the fact that they have been used a long time in other indication, we don't know if they're safe to inject into the knee, shoulder, or hip. To date, there hasn't been an extensive study ever performed or published showing the safety of amniotic stem cell injections in orthopedic applications. Think about that. Not a single study! Patients are paying thousands of dollars for injections of dead cells, and, we don't even know if this stuff is safe! In fact, they're not even indicated in their FDA registration for that use.
If amniotic products had turned out to have viable stem cells, believe me, Regenexx would be their biggest client, but my mother once said if it sounds too good to be true, it isn't true. Things like this amniotic product deception are why we spend so much money studying things. At Regenexx, for example, we have followed the long-term safety of our bone marrow stem cell procedure through a nonprofit registry. We've tracked 2,372 patients with 3,000 procedures out to nine years.
The Clinic Setup
Now that you know to stay away from clinics telling you that the amniotic products they inject have stem cells, let's talk about making sure your stem cell clinic is properly set up to do orthopedic injections. Why? One of the trends we've been seeing is that practice management companies are sending nurse practitioners or physician assistants to chiropractic or acupuncture offices to inject patients. Getting a stem cell procedure done in those settings isn't the same as getting it done in an office or procedure suite that's set up to do stem cell injections. There are a few things at a minimum that your stem cell clinic should have.
Musculoskeletal ultrasound equipment is designed to make sure cells the doctor places stem cells in relevant parts of the musculoskeletal system.
Full Surgical Monitoring
Surgical monitoring equipment measures your vital signs during your procedure to make sure you're doing well.
Advanced Fluoroscopy Imaging
Advanced fluoroscopy allows us to image your spine and place the injection in particular areas of joints like the knee, hip, or shoulder.
Oxygen is imperative in many emergency situations. Oxygen is not something you're going to see in a chiropractor's or acupuncturist's office.
Automated Defibrillator and Crash Cart
Having an automated defibrillator and a crash cart available is critical, as it assures us that we can handle any and all emergencies.
Not only is it important to have the right equipment, but it's also important to have doctors who know how to use the equipment should something go wrong. In a chiropractor's or an acupuncturist's office, it is unlikely that a crash cart is available or that there is a medical professional who knows what to do if something goes wrong.
The upshot? Now that you know that amniotic "stem cells" are one big great deception, you understand a little something about any medical provider who bought the little white lie that the medical sales rep was pitching. Make sure your stem cell clinic is using actual stem cells and the proper equipment to place them. Make sure there is emergency equipment available and your procedure is being performed by a skilled medical professional. It's important to also note that amniotic stem cells may also be marketed under other names, such as “placental stem cells” or “amniotic stem cell factors.” We've also seen them called "fetal stem cells." So buyer beware!
comments powered by
- health tips